TOPAZ:  Get bitten or bite their partner. Why not both? If he has to choose he likes being bitten more, but he doesn’t mind doing some nibbling biting either.

CITRINE: Give a striptease or clothed sex. If it’s him giving the striptease then clothed sex all the way. Not that he doesn’t enjoy clothesless sex or stripteases, but he’d rather be on the receiving end of the latter. And clothed sex implies something more dangerous– either sex in a public location or a place they might get caught. Or something needy. And that’s a little more enticing.

QUARTZ: A dangerous partner or a risky location. Risky location. Newt’s pretty non-judgemental but if he finds a person dangerous it means they really are and so… Nah, he’s not about that kind of life. He’s a sexual being and enjoys sex and any potential for it to cross a line he (or a partner) isn’t comfortable with keeps him away.

EMERALD: Dominating or being dominated. Dominating. I mentioned this when I started his blog in a headcanon about his sexuality, but Newt isn’t a wallflower– He’s sexually explorative and enjoys finding ways to make his partners come undone. He likes leading and taking control in these moments even though he’s not so good out of it. It’s not that he won’t let others take dominance– A particularly intriguing partner can absolutely get him to be.